Monday, August 01, 2005

AUGUST 2005

When two plus two equals April

In Imogen Stubbs' ideal world, schools would nurture, celebrate, inspire and teach dyslexic children, like her son.

My nine-year-old son was excited when I asked him to help me with this article. But he didn't want to have to write anything. After 30 agonising minutes and the promise of a baseball glove, this is what he produced:

"when I do riting and pariigrafs my brayn is uncunferdbl and herts and i get the writ word but wen it travls down my arm it disapeeurs befour it coms out of my hand and sumtymes im chrying."

This is a child who draws with an astonishing sense of colour, is always joyous and clowning and tender, and incredibly sensitive to other people's moods and feelings. He adores babies and animals. He can spend hours chatting to an old fisherman or helping the gardener or whittling a piece of wood. He loves moving his body, hurling himself around on a skateboard. He adores kite-flying and building things and kayaking and cooking.

However, he still has trouble remembering my brother's name. And only two years ago, when asked what you got when you added two plus two, he replied: "April?"

It is as though his thoughts are lost in translation as they move from pictures to words.

For many dyslexic children, the experience of reading and writing is like driving in a foreign country - everything seems to be on the wrong side, going in the wrong direction. Everyone seems to be travelling faster than you. It requires exhausting concentration - and you experience a sense of tension, fear and total isolation as everyone roars past, hooting and looking at you as if you're an idiot. When you finally reach your destination, after many wrong turns and a circuitous route that has taken an insanely long time, you then have no desire ever to get behind the wheel again. Meanwhile, your hosts have gone off to a party without you.

And yet. And yet. You could excel behind the wheel, if only you were on familiar roads.

Dyslexia is not a disease and it has nothing to do with a lack of intelligence. It is a neurologically based, often familial disorder that interferes with the acquisition and processing of language.

One in 10 children has some form of dyslexia. Of course, there is no such thing as a standard dyslexic but there do seem to be common characteristics: astonishing artistic and mechanical gifts and the potential for intuitive, highly creative, multi-dimensional thought processes. There can, however, be erratic access to logic, maths and word skills. Frequently, there are short-term memory and concentration problems, slower thought-processing speeds and the kind of non-linear thinking patterns that British comedian Eddie Izzard, himself dyslexic, has turned into a virtue.

The biggest problem seems to be that the large-classed, exam-oriented school system is catastrophic for most dyslexic children. It does not and cannot play to their strengths. To learn differently, you have to be taught differently. Yet mainstream teachers have neither the time, resources nor training to help children outside the norm, and both are judged by exam results.

For such children, there is one overwhelming lesson they learn from their school days: if you are down on the floor yet again, either literally or metaphorically, there is a great attraction in staying down because you are not exposed to the terror and humiliation of falling down again.

Is it any surprise that 70 per cent of people in prison have learning difficulties? How much cheaper and more humane to be there at the beginning, ready to catch them if they fall. Even a child who thinks two plus two equals April could work that out.

I am writing this article not because I have the answers but because I am exploding with questions fuelled by anguish, incomprehension, anger and a passionate belief that all children - every single one - deserve an education from which they will emerge liking themselves.

In most schools, it is a case of all children are equal but some children are more equal than others. So what do we do as parents? How do we help our son survive intact in school and yet retain his uniqueness? How can we ensure that we find the right path before he becomes withdrawn and frightened and wears his glorious hat of many colours like a dunce's cap?

Or should we just say: "This is how this wonderful, luminous child is", and let be? We have no idea what to do. It seems overwhelmingly clear that our son's life should not be judged by exams - but do exam-free schools exist?

In my heart, I want to keep my son at home and protect him and home-educate him. his, to me, means encouraging him to make impressionist paintings and pottery, going to films and plays, gardening and singing, making up stories, trying out instruments, building a sailing-boat, and taking him on camel rides across Rajasthan.

I want to fill him up with challenges that will inspire and exhilarate him,
rather than abandon him to "get through" the experience of school, where every book and lesson is a different form of reproach.

But, of course, my idyllic notion is probably naive. What about team sports and a social life? What strains does home education put on the rest of the family? Would he still have to study for the same exams?

He is in a lovely school that does its utmost to provide extra help for a few sessions a week. But, even so, he has started to come home saying that he's got a "wonky" mind; that children say "Hello durr-brain, are you receiving me?"; that he'll never ever be able to spell February.

He beams with pride when he receives certificates of merit. But in big school you don't get them for being a good clearer-upper or kind to little ones in the playground. Being the goofy kid who plays the fool can suddenly become being the fool.

Anchoring his concentration is like tethering a kite on a windy day or stalking a kangaroo. It feels as though it's against nature. But you also need vigilance against laziness: dyslexia can easily become an excuse for perpetual chilling-out or an unwillingness to have a go.

Many children develop illnesses in order to avoid school and potential humiliation. I'm sure we are not the only parents who have subjected their child to an MRI scan because of mystery aches and pains.

My great fear is that as he gets older, our son will stop sharing his hurt with us, that he will push it deep down and cover it over. I know pubescence is a tricky time for boys; they fend off most questions with a shrug and "dunno" or "whatever" or "fine". It will become much harder to assess whether "fine" actually means "Please help me, I'm lost and frightened and I have no idea what anyone's talking about."

And then, as his self-esteem disintegrates, I'll no longer get a sunshine smile, brimful of the bliss of my unequivocal approval. Instead, I'll witness a defensive retreat into misplaced clowning, bitterness and cynicism. "Yeah, sure, I'm your unique, wonderful boy. How? Give me one example of something I shine at? . . . Exactly."

If we get his education wrong, then the shimmering of his personality will disappear with the harm of the years.

I have to confess that until I had children, I was never too interested in dyslexia. I thought it was something that could be solved with spell-check and a calculator.

Dyslexia is not an arresting word. It does not begin to speak of the all-encompassing nature of the condition or anything like the colours of its palette and the complexity of its woes and joys.

In many ways, we are lucky. Our son was diagnosed with dyslexia relatively early on, when it was clear he had problems with his retentive memory, probably not helped by the fact that I had initially sent him to a French school. That said, he has a truly refined appreciation of boyish women who smoke and read Tintin.

At his small private school, he is provided with between one and two hours of specialist help in maths and literacy, along with other children who have the same, yet inevitably different, "learning differences". With the best will in the world, it is clear that the specialist teachers have far more work than they can really accommodate.

What else have we done? We have leapt on every bandwagon going. We have chucked fish oils down his gullet; we have had him focusing on light-beams in dark rooms; we have encouraged him to walk backwards down a line, counting plastic frogs; we have watched him balancing on boards while catching bean-bags, occasionally between his teeth. It all merges into a slightly lunatic blur.

Maybe some things help, but then maybe so does changing the breakfast cereal. It is so hard to tell what is real improvement and what is part of natural development or simply your desperation to believe. Yet every new "solution" demands an expensive and time-consuming commitment.

It is a growth industry. There are more and more impressionable people out there desperate for a miracle "cure" for dyslexia. But dyslexia does not need a cure. It needs to be diagnosed early so that appropriate help can be provided immediately. Then life-long learning needs to be backed up by life-long support and motivation. In an ideal world.

Inevitably, though, many parents are told that their children can "get by" in mainstream education. I doubt whether the word "flourish" has ever been used in this context. It involves "inclusion" or extra help within mainstream schools. Inclusion is a lovely ideal. But what are severely dyslexic children being included in? The child may be physically present and notionally part of the class. But whether he is included in the experience of success is another matter. He is not discriminated against but, ironically, this worthy policy may not always be appropriate.

The problem is that inclusion can easily become exclusion unless it involves academic segregation, with the whole peer group mixing only for non-academic activities. Inclusion also requires the child's classmates to demonstrate immense generosity, tolerance and goodwill.

But surely I am not the only parent who feels that my child needs a completely reinvented curriculum? Academic qualifications are not the only valid achievement. Crafts and skills and apprenticeships look wonderful from where I am at the moment.

According to Alex Tait, a charismatic specialist teacher whom I'd happily kidnap, and Patience Thompson, an authority on spLD, specific learning difficulty (a form of dyslexia), children with specific learning difficulty require a multisensory approach, rather than one that is word-based and linear. You need to reinvent the wheel, so to speak, every lesson.

Children need to be taught in a way that is both dynamic and unexpected, while at the same time they should be incredibly well-informed about the timetable. Otherwise, there is constant fear that humiliations are about to burst upon them around the corner.

Equally, problems must not be treated with unquestioning acceptance. The school must see the potential that the child may not want to let them see because the prospect of going after something and then failing is too scary.

In other words, school needs to address the emotional, intellectual and social development of the children in a safe environment, away from mockery. Teaching should not be focused so much on exam results as on instilling self-belief.

That there are "special needs" co-ordinators in most schools now is a tremendous advance, yet often they are dealing with a mish-mash of problems. Two sessions a week is well-intentioned but a severely dyslexic child needs all lessons to be recalibrated in order to make the academic side of school accessible.

I suppose that my ideal is a combination of orthodox and unorthodox. Children clearly need literacy and core basics, such as maths, to be able to cope in society. But then they should be allowed to go off-piste in order to discover and develop non-academic skills that could become the foundation of their future careers. Then children could emerge from their school days not feeling damaged but possessed of strengths that genuinely define their difference and uniqueness in a positive way.

Many clever and pioneering people owe some of their talent, skill and fame to being different, not in spite of it. Famous dyslexics include Tom Cruise, Robin Williams, Agatha Christie, John Lennon, Nigel Kennedy, J. F. Kennedy and W. B. Yeats.

Sometimes I feel that there is something immensely precious and enviable about the way my son seems to perceive the world. I look at a tree, and a noisy internal commentary keeps any sensory experience at arm's length. Something is lost in translation. (As Tom Stoppard points out: "The names for things don't come first - words stagger after, hopelessly trying to become the sensation.") My son responds in a much more instinctive and emotional way: he senses the brown-greenness against the blue, the nice-smellingness of the pine-needles, the roughness of the bark.

There is a real beauty and value in responding to the essence of something in its pure state. Hopkins called this the "inscape", the unified complex of characteristics that gives each thing its uniqueness and that differentiates it from other things:

Each mortal thing does one thing and the same:
. . . myself it speaks and spells, Crying 'What I do is me: for that I came'. (G. M. Hopkins)

Whatever happens, we must fight to retain every child's inscape intact.

"somtiyms i get the best good ideya in my head and its like Miss Wakins Me Me ME! but wen she sez yes its gon like a rabit down a hoel not even the litle nose peking -jus dark mistry."
- Telegraph

By Imogen Stubbs, The Age
July 25, 2005
http://www.theage.com.au/news/education-news/when-two-plus-two-equals-
april/2005/07/22/1121539155781.html?oneclick=true>


The ABCs of Stuttering: New DVD for Parents and Teachers
Give your child’s teacher a copy on the first day of school

When teachers hear a child stutter, the immediate reaction is one of concern mixed with a host of urgent questions:
- Should I call on the student in class, or will that only make it worse?
- How should I handle teasing and bullying by other students?
- What should I do about reading aloud in class?

The Stuttering Foundation is making Stuttering: Straight Talk for Teachers available on DVD just in time for the back-to-school season. This 20-minute DVD helps parents and teachers understand how stuttering can affect children of all ages in the classroom.

The highlight of the DVD is the children who discuss their experiences in the classroom and share what was helpful for them.

“Even when I knew the answer, I wouldn’t raise my hand because I was worried about what others might think,” says Umberto, a teenager in the video. He added that giving a classroom presentation on stuttering to the entire class has made him feel more at ease.

“At the beginning of the school year, I was embarrassed to read aloud in front of my teacher and friends because of my stuttering,” says Kate. She worked with her teacher to make a plan about how she could practice first at home and then individually with her teacher.

Martin offers a different perspective. “I feel confident and even though I might mess up when I talk, I’m not ashamed. I still want the teacher to call on me even though I might be having a bad day.”

Noted speech-language pathologists Bill Murphy, M.A., of Purdue University and Kristin Chmela, M.A., of Northwestern University present practical strategies teachers can use immediately to help children feel more comfortable talking in the classroom.

“The courage and honesty of the children sharing their experiences helps teachers find solutions for the children in their class,” says Lisa Scott, Ph.D., of Florida State University and co-producer of the DVD.

At school, children who stutter often face bullying and teasing. This treatment by other students sometimes causes more anxiety than does the speech disorder itself.

“Even the children who receive therapy to help them speak more fluently continue to have negative feelings as they grow older,” Murphy says. “Their ability to communicate is still hindered by the shame and embarrassment they feel about stuttering, which is often brought on by teasing.”

Murphy suggests teachers make stuttering an open topic for discussion in the classroom. One exercise a teacher can use is to discuss famous people who stutter.

NBA basketball star Kenyon Martin, news anchor John Stossel, and actors James Earl Jones and Nicholas Brendon are just a few of the many celebrities who struggle with stuttering. A list of famous people who stutter and a downloadable poster can be found at www.stutteringhelp.org.

Elementary school teacher Katie Lenell says, “This DVD is an excellent resource for educators at all grade levels. I now feel more at ease having a child who stutters in my classroom.”

The DVD, which is offered free to all public libraries, comes with a 42-page handbook of additional information and resources. A videotape version is also available. For more information, contact the Stuttering Foundation at 1-800-992-9392 or online at www.stutteringhelp.org or www.tartamudez.org (Spanish).

Tips for talking with a child who stutters

1. Don’t tell the child to slow down or “relax.”

2. Speak with the child in an unhurried way, pausing frequently. Wait a few seconds after the child finishes speaking before you begin to speak. This slows down the overall pace of conversation.

3. Use your facial expressions, eye contact, and other body language to convey to the child that you are listening to the content of her message and not how she is talking.

4. Don’t complete words for the child or talk for him.

5. Don’t make stuttering something to be ashamed of. Talk about stuttering just like any other matter.

ArriveNet
July 14, 2005
http://press.arrivenet.com/edu/article.php/668747.html%20


Tears before bedtime

A sleep-deprived child may appear the opposite of sleepy - so much so, finds Vivienne Parry, that he could be wrongly diagnosed with an attention deficit disorder

By the age of two, children have spent 13 months of their lives asleep. Sleep, as every parent knows, is central to kids' wellbeing. But as parents know equally well, bedtime can be the biggest battleground of family life.

There are three main sleep difficulties in children: falling asleep, staying asleep and being too sleepy in the daytime. Every parent experiences at least one of them at some point or other. Perhaps because of this, and because disturbed nights have become regarded as almost normal, we fail to appreciate just how important sleep is for our children's health. In fact, sleep has a major impact on their physical development and growth: when your mum told you you wouldn't grow up big and strong if you didn't go to bed, she was spot on. Research has shown that children who do not sleep as much as they should are smaller than they ought to be.

But the impact of sleep is not just physical. Sleep also has a profound influence on children's behaviour, emotions and ability to learn. Remember how gran told us to "sleep on it"? Children (and adults) need sleep to consolidate new learning, be it French vocab or bike riding. In one study, cutting children's sleep from 10 to nine hours a night had a marked effect on working memory and verbal task ability, in addition to making children irritable and "oppositional" - a marvellous medical turn of phrase that encompasses everything we dread as parents, from truculent defiance to constant picking of fights with siblings. And that's with just one hour less sleep a night, a time period that many of us would consider insignificant.

"The problem with children and sleep is that while we all know what a sleep-deprived adult looks like, we can't say the same of a sleep-deprived child." So says Paul Gringras, consultant in paediatric neurodisability at Guy's and St Thomas's NHS Foundation Trust and director of the trust's paediatric sleep disorder clinic. Such kids, he says, may not even appear sleepy: in fact, they may appear the reverse.

What all this means is that children's sleep disorders are not often recognised as such, although they may well be referred to hospitals for treatment of the behavioural or learning problems that occur because of their sleep deprivation. For instance, children with narcolepsy, a classic sleep disorder, may initially be referred for specialist assessment because of concern about "underachievement".

The situation is compounded by a lack of paediatric sleep disorder clinics. While Chicago alone has three, Britain has fewer than 10 for the whole country; most are adjuncts to adult sleep clinics.

Gringras sees plenty of children who have neurodisabilities such as autism and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) - and, he says, about 50% of them also have sleep problems. For children with ADHD, popularly perceived to be on the go all the time, this is not a surprise. Yet what is completely counterintuitive is that many of those with ADHD also experience daytime sleepiness, revealed by something called a multiple sleep latency test. It involves repeatedly bringing a child into a very dull room and asking them to lie down and go to sleep. "No normal child ever falls asleep in these circumstances," says Gringras, "whereas children with narcolepsy reliably fall asleep every time. The real surprise is that children with ADHD often fall asleep, too."

Some paediatric sleep specialists, such as Stephen Sheldon, director of the Sleep Medicine Centre at Chicago's Children's Memorial Hospital, go so far as to say that as many as 30% of children with ADHD have been wrongly diagnosed. "There's a proportion of youngsters that have sleep pathology causing their daytime symptoms that appear virtually identical to ADHD." Gringras does not go this far, but does say that sorting out underlying sleep problems can make a real difference to behaviour in those diagnosed with ADHD, so much so that in many cases drug treatments, such as Ritalin, are no longer necessary.

There is an increasing body of evidence pointing to a link between sleep problems and attention deficit disorders. For instance, work from the University of Michigan in 2002 by Dr Ronald Chervin showed that children who snored faced double the risk of being inattentive and hyperactive. "If there is indeed a cause-and-effect link, sleep problems could represent a major public health issue," says Chervin. But many paediatricians feel that disordered sleep is a consequence of ADHD, not a cause of it.

No one sleep disorder is linked to ADHD. Just as in adults, there are many different types of sleep problem, some of which can be revealed simply by careful history taking. Nor are overnight stays in a sleep lab always required as for adults. Children may be given an "Actiwatch" to wear at home, which records movement detection to a computer chip over a two-week period before the information is downloaded on to a PC for analysis.

"Basically, it tells us how much napping is going on," says Gringras. He points out that when parents think their darling is asleep, he may actually be reading under the bedclothes with a torch or, more likely, texting his equally wide-awake mates.

Even for those children reaching a tertiary referral centre such as the one at
St. Thomas's, the Little Angel-style behavioural approach is still of value, especially if the parents are supported by professionals. So-called "sleep hygiene" measures such as a bedroom that is dark and only for sleeping, consistent bedtimes and daytime exercise can make a big difference on their own.

A forgotten aspect is that sleep needs the right prompts, such as darkness. Light-emitting computer screens wake the brain up, not put it to sleep, so it makes sense to ban the PC from the bedroom.

Treatments for paediatric sleep disorders vary depending on the type identified. Sleep phase disturbances, for instance, are treated with light. Adult body rhythms, which naturally run to near 25-hour cycles, are reset every day by time cues, such as morning light, ensuring that we adhere to a 24-hour cycle. Circadian rhythm disorders are common in babies and toddlers, who may be wide awake when everyone else in the house is fast asleep, and vice versa. Somewhere between 18 months and four years old, children develop adult rhythms. But about one in 15 children between the ages of five and 13 continues to march to the beat of their own personal time drum. Essentially, what these children have is jet lag without having moved through any time zones. And like us after a red-eye overnight flight from New York, they are irritable, "oppositional" and sleepy, and can't concentrate or learn properly.

The answer for these children is not a fixed bedtime, but a firmly anchored morning wake-up time. Although letting them sleep an hour later is OK, a three-hour lie-in at weekends is disastrous because their bodies will reset their clocks every day to this rhythm. The most effective treatment is a simulated dawn at a fixed time each morning using light therapy.

Needless to say, most kids can't or won't sit still for long enough, so sleep physiologists (specialist healthcare scientists who collect sleep data) have to be endlessly inventive. Visors that look like something out of Nasa are one option. These have a light source under the brim, which, being near the eye, does not have to be too bright. Also effective in some cases are carefully scheduled doses of melatonin, the hormone that is slave to the body clock and which carries its messages.

Another common problem is obstructive sleep apnoea. In adults, this is accompanied by heavy snoring. Children with this respiratory condition may not snore, but still wake up up to 12 times an hour, making them severely sleep deprived. Because their breathing seems normal during the day and even for much of the night, except in REM (dreaming) sleep, the real cause of poor daytime performance often goes unrecognised.

Here it is measurements obtained in a sleep lab that are the clincher for diagnosis. These rely on healthcare scientists whose job it is to wire up, cajole and comfort children, and then stay up all night to take the necessary measurements, showing extraordinary dedication. These children's respiratory difficulties are very often bound up with enlarged adenoids and tonsils. Shrinking them with steroid sprays or removing them surgically may provide a complete cure.

In adults, the link between sleep disorders and health disorders such as high blood pressure and coronary heart disease has long been recognised. Poor sleep in children is already linked with obesity, and it is known that children with sleep disorders are more likely to become adults with sleep disorders; but there may be a lot more to unravel about the dangers of doing without sleep when you're a kid. It's definitely not something to shut our eyes to.

The Guardian
July 26, 2005
http://www.guardian.co.uk/g2/story/0,,1535951,00.html


Girls' autism 'under-diagnosed'

Girls with autism may not be identified because they do not show traditional signs of the disorder, an expert warns.

Children with autistic spectrum disorders have poor social and communication skills.

Hyperactivity, and interests in technical hobbies have been seen as characteristics of the disorder.

But Christopher Gillberg, of the National Centre of Autism Studies, said girls were often passive and collected information on people, not things.

Around 535,000 people in the UK are estimated to have autistic spectrum disorders.

The number of boys diagnosed is much greater than the number of girls, but Professor Gillberg said the difference in incidence may not be as great as currently thought.

'Outsiders'

His theory is partly influenced by studies which did not find what they were expected to.

Researchers had looked at the male X chromosome, to see if genetic faults there could influence a boy's risk of developing the condition.

But no conclusive link has been found.

Professor Gillberg said: "Scientists had been very surprised that, so far, so little has come out of research into the X chromosome.

"But it may be that girls present differently to boys.

"The number of females with autism spectrum disorders may be under-diagnosed."

He said studies, including one his team had carried out into women with anorexia
who were also autistic, as well as his own clinical practice, had shown the gender difference.

He added: "Autism may be behind many cases of anorexia. A girl may be withdrawn and uncommunicative, without attracting attention, but when she develops a calorie fixation it becomes a serious problem.

"Counting calories may be a manifestation of autism.

"I've seen quite a number of cases where the anorexia has become completely entrenched because people haven't understood that underlying the eating disorder is autism."

Lists

Professor Gillberg said that, at an earlier age girls with autism were likely to be more passive and not as active or aggressive as boys with autism are - and may be seen as simply shy.

"With some girls, there's a perception they are outsiders, someone who can't really mix with other children.

"They may tend to either avoid other children, or be on the periphery of the group."

He said boys were likely to show interest in technical or maths-related hobbies, whereas girls were more interested in people.

"They may have hobbies such as compiling books about their 'so-called' friends, and may make lists of their names and the colour of their eyes and hair, but not actually interact with them."

Professor Gillberg said girls may be perceived as simply shy, and parents and teachers may not realise there's a problem.

He added that differences in the way girls and boys learn to speak could also mask signs of autistic disorders.

"Girls tend to use language immediately, and use new words as soon as they hear them. Boys have longer periods of repeating what they know and processing what they are learning."

He said both genders may have the same combination of autism genes, but girls' natural linguistic ability may hide the associated language difficulties.

"Autistic spectrum disorders may be more difficult to pick up in girls, because
they have superior linguistic abilities."

Judith Gould, director of the National Autistic Society's Diagnostic Centre, said: "We still know so little about this complex lifelong disability that it is essential we continue to question current thinking and suggest alternative theories for its prevalence.

"We would certainly agree we are probably missing autism in girls due to the different way in which it often manifests itself in females.

"We would also agree that anorexia, which is predominantly diagnosed in girls,
could be linked to autism in an unknown proportion of cases."

BBC NEWS
July 28, 2005
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/health/4630705.stm


'Gene test' for autism in sight

Scientists who have discovered a gene linked to autism believe they can use the new knowledge to work out an individual's risk of the condition.

The French team from IntegraGen SA hope to have a working risk assessment test on the market by the end of 2006.

The gene sits on chromosome 16 and holds the DNA code for a protein that plays a central role in brain function.

Experts said the Molecular Psychiatry study was promising but that it was premature to talk about an autism test.

For their study, the French authors looked at 116 families where at least one member had autism.

By analysing the DNA from these individuals they found a region on chromosome 16 - PRKCB1 - appeared to be linked with autism.

PRKCB1 is expressed in granule cells in the cerebellum of the brain. Its associated protein is involved in transmitting signals from the granule cells to the Purkinje cells. Both these cells help relay messages in and out of the brain.

Researchers have already found a decreased number of both granule and Purkinje cells in the brains of people with autism.

Discovery

Lead researcher Dr. Jorg Hager said: "This is the first time that the protein PRKCB1, and the brain functions that it is involved with, have been associated with autism.

"We think that this is a significant development."

The test they are devising will check for the presence of four genes, including PRKCB1, linked to autism.

They envisage that families who already have a child with autism would be able to have their other children tested at an early age - around 18 months.

If the cheek swab sample is positive, it means the infant is at increased risk of developing autism and early interventions such as behavioural educational programmes, can be started, said Dr Hager.

Around 535,000 people in the UK have an autism spectrum disorder.

The condition affects the way people communicate and relate to people around them and sufferers have problems with everyday social interaction.

They have a limited ability to develop friendships and find it hard to understand other people's emotional feelings.

Other researchers have been attempting to identify genes predisposing people to autism, which are thought to be as many as 20.

In 1995 the International Molecular Genetic Study of Autism was set up. It has found areas on chromosome 7 that might be involved.

Future drug hope

Professor Sir Michael Rutter, an expert in autism at the Institute of Psychiatry, said: "These are interesting and promising findings. We need more studies to confirm them."

He did not think it would necessarily be helpful or practical to use the knowledge to develop a risk assessment test because not all of the people with the genes would necessarily develop severe autism.

"The real potential for research of this kind is that it can, in conjunction with other research, lead to an understanding of what the disease processes are. In turn, that could lead to new treatments."

The National Autistic Society agreed.

A spokeswoman said: "If the genes responsible could be identified the possibility of new types of treatment and preventing the more severe manifestations of the disorder becomes stronger."

She said a genetic test to diagnose a pre-disposition to an autistic spectrum disorder was not, at present, possible because there were too many genetic and environmental factors involved in the condition.

Story from BBC NEWS:
July 19, 2005
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4697057.stm


Groups argue vaccine, autism link

On the eve of a scheduled rally in Washington by parents of children with autism, leaders of federal health agencies and medical societies called a press briefing Tuesday to emphasize their message that childhood vaccines are safe and don't cause autism.

"We don't know what causes autism, that's a fact," said Julie Gerberding, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. But what is known, she said, is that in studies involving thousands of children, "the predominance of evidence does not reveal an association between thimerosal (a vaccine preservative) and autism."

Duane Alexander, director of the National Institute of Child Health Development, part of the National Institutes of Health, said NIH has increased its budget for research to find genetic and environmental factors that cause autism and to find better ways to diagnose the disorder accurately and as early as possible.

The debate over the possible role of vaccines in autism has simmered for years. But it gained new impetus this summer with the publication in Rolling Stone and Salon.com of an article by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., which claimed medical authorities deliberately hid evidence of a connection between autism and thimerosal. That followed publication of a heavily advertised book, Evidence of Harm, by author David Kirby. Media celebrity Don Imus and several legislators have also weighed in.

Thimerosal, a mercury-based vaccine preservative, is no longer used in the vaccines routinely recommended for children under age 6, Gerberding said. In 1999, health officials recommended that it be phased out of vaccines for babies to reduce their overall exposure to mercury.

It is still used in most flu shots, though preservative-free versions are available. Trace amounts of thimerosal still are in many vaccines, including those given to babies, because vaccine makers use the chemical during the manufacturing process.

Around 95% of children in the USA receive all the recommended vaccines by the time they start school. But health officials are concerned that could change, as a parent-driven movement linking thimerosal to increasing rates of autism gains steam and raises questions about vaccine safety.

Food and Drug Administration official Murray Lumpkin said vaccines have been "one of the mainstays" of public health, but "any kind of therapy is only as good as those willing to take it. One of our major concerns and goals is for parents to have confidence in the vaccines their health-care workers are recommending."

That message may not be getting through to activist groups planning to rally today at the Capitol to call for a ban on mercury in all medical products. Among groups participating are Moms Against Mercury, the National Autism Association and Safe Minds, whose director, Sallie Bernard, said health officials "missed the point" in Tuesday's briefing.

"The question is what did thimerosal do to these kids," she said. "The answer we got is they're really not looking at it. ... We heard some of the people today say 'we're researching the cause of autism,' but they're looking at everything but thimerosal."

By Anita Manning
USA Today
http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2005-07-19-autism_x.htm


Very Premature Babies found At Risk For Disability

Children born prematurely at weights of 2.2 pounds or less during the 1990s have high rates of mental and physical disability despite advances in treatment that doctors had hoped would improve their conditions, researchers reported today.

Although such infants were much more likely to survive than those born in previous decades -- the survival rate was 70 percent in the 1990s, compared with 50 percent in the 1970s and '80s -- they were just as likely to suffer from significant disabilities.

Asthma, cerebral palsy, vision and hearing disorders, low IQ, poor school performance and social difficulties are among the problems described in the Journal of the American Medical Association by doctors at Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital in Cleveland.

Such disabilities were far more common in the children born prematurely than in normal-weight children from similar backgrounds. For example, 38 percent of those born prematurely had IQs below 85, as opposed to 14 percent of the normal weight children. Among the premature, 21 percent had asthma, compared with 9 percent of those with normal weight.

"We were astonished by the high number who had at least one of those things," said Dr. Deanne Wilson-Costello, an author of the article in the journal. "The majority had some kind of special need."

Advances in treatment helped infants' lungs to mature and helped to prevent brain hemorrhages that had been a major source of problems in the past, but did not help to prevent other types of brain injury caused by prematurity,
she said.

The study was the first to look at how very premature children born at the Cleveland hospital in the 1990s were faring when they reached school age. It included 219 8-year-old children born from 1992 to 1995. Most were from the inner city, and about 61 percent were black.

Other experts said the findings, though disappointing, were not a big surprise, given the fragility of tiny babies like those in the study who were born, on average, at 26 weeks of pregnancy, weighing less than 2 pounds.

Deciding whether to try to save such premature babies, given their high odds of having serious disabilities, has been a wrenching issue.

"Over the last few years, I think the trend has been for more intervention with these very tiny babies," said Dr. Richard Polin, the director of neonatology at Morgan Stanley Children's Hospital of New York- Presbyterian. Decisions are usually made by doctors and parents on a case-by- case basis, he said, adding that most hospitals would strongly recommend trying to save babies 26 weeks and over. Below that age, he said, many doctors would lay out the risks for parents and give them the option of not pursuing treatment.

"It's extraordinarily controversial, what I'm saying," Polin said. "Some people will get incensed about giving those families a decision about whether to go ahead."

Denise Grady, New York Times
San Francisco Chronicle
July 25, 2005
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2005/07/20/MNG8CDQJR71.DTL


'Smart cards' to reward well-behaved teenagers

Teenagers are to be offered discounts on items such as cinema tickets and sporting activities in exchange for good behaviour.

They will be issued with "smart cards" - which will give them reductions on services as part of the Government's attempts to control anti-social behaviour. The cash discounts could be offered if, for instance, they volunteer for community service. However, they can be taken away again if a youngster lands in trouble with police and faces prosecution.

Plans for the new "smart cards" will be outlined in a Government Green Paper to be published this morning putting forward proposals for a shake-up of youth services.

The range of activities covered by the "smart card" could include public transport, libraries, cinemas, museums, a whole host of sporting activities and even shopping.

The theme of the Green Paper will be to offer teenagers incentives for good behaviour and disincentives for behaving badly.

Children's Minister Beverley Hughes indicated yesterday that the scheme will be "about celebrating when young people are doing well, as well as being able - through sanctions or not involving young people - to point to the fact that they have responsibilities as well as rights and if they don't meet their responsibilities, they jeopardise those rights".

"We are going to be proposing practical ways in which incentives and sanctions
could be built into the way young people access activities or decide to spend their time," she added.

Officials at the Department for Education and Skills discounted any suggestion
that the so-called "smart cards" could be used as an identity card for teenagers.

Any "smart card" scheme would be delivered locally with decisions taken locally as to what activities and services would qualify for the card. Schemes would not be compulsory for the teenagers and local councils would not be compelled to take part in them.

Today's much delayed Green Paper was originally due to be published last year when the thrust of the paper was more about improving youth service provision.

It has been rewritten to reflect Prime Minister Tony Blair's growing concern with anti-social behaviour.

Meanwhile, the Conservatives are today announcing plans for a new commission to investigate the delivery of special education needs in the UK.

By Richard Grice, Education Editor
The Independent Online Edition
July 18, 2005
http://education.independent.co.uk/news/article299978.ece


Special education teacher uses acting, drama background to teach children

David Braga dropped out of high school and later followed his love for drama and acting to the American Conservatory Theater in San Francisco.

Being a teacher wasn't his original plan.

But after getting his degree in theater arts from the ACT, Braga felt he needed to do more with his life and sought a teaching credential from San Francisco State University.

There he met a professor who offered advice that led Braga to a career teaching special education children. He is teaching at two Turlock elementary schools — Cunningham and Osborn.

"One of my professors in special education (Adriana Schueller) told me that education and drama is a perfect match for teaching special education students, and it has been," he said. "If I weren't teaching, I would want to be on stage.

"And a great thing about being a teacher is you're always on stage and you have a captive audience."

Until last year, Braga kept his hand in the theater as an assistant artistic director and performer with the Patterson Repertory Theatre.

Before coming to Turlock, he taught special education at Wardlaw Elementary School in Vallejo.

With his father in the Navy, Braga traveled a lot, but spent most of his early years in San Diego.

After he dropped out of high school, he attended Lincoln Continuation School in San Leandro and passed the General Educational Development test.

Braga shared his thoughts on other topics:

FAVORITE TEACHING TOOL: "I pride myself on being pretty flexible. I'm not a direct-instruction type tea-cher. I use improv and flexibility to find a way to make it work for a student. Another favorite tool is the individual education program we use to teach special education kids."

ADVICE FOR OTHER TEACHERS: "Find joy in every child."

ADVICE FOR SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS: "Be flexible when it comes to needs for special education children."

MY FAVORITE THING ABOUT BEING A TEACHER: "I have a drama club at Cunningham Elementary School and I bring a play that Kaye Osborn's drama program has done at Lakewood Elementary School in Modesto. She lets us have the old sets and we use the materials from Lakewood to put on great plays for the students, their parents and the community in the old auditorium. We've been successful."

WHAT'S NEW AND EXCITING IN MY CLASSROOM: "Just getting back to school and meeting new kids. I look forward to seeing what kids are in my class next year and working with Kaye … to pick the next play for Cunningham Elementary School."

WHAT I'D TELL GOV. SCHWARZENEGGER: "Teachers are professionals and we need to be treated as such. We've worked very hard for our pensions. Leave our pensions alone."

Do you know an inspiring and insightful kindergarten-through-12th-grade teacher who's making a difference and should be recognized? Contact Daryl Farnsworth at 578-2337 or dfarnsworth@modbee.com.

Daryl Farnsworth, Bee Staff Writer
MODBEE.COM
July 25, 2005
http://www.modbee.com/local/story/10960150p-11725912c.html


Blind campers have fun, learn

Casper Mountain stands just south of town as a refuge for fleeting moments away from the routine or an escape into nature. To the visually handicapped, Casper Mountain extends more than that with a few weeks of precious hospitality each summer.

The Allen H. Stewart Blind Camp is held for two weeks each summer on the mountain, Gary Olsen, camp director, said. Olsen is completely blind and has been attending camp since 1969. He began teaching in 1973. The first week of camp is for children between the ages of nine and 15 and the second for adults over 16.

The campers are taught braille, orientation and mobility, adaptive technology for computers, cooking skills, cleaning skills, physical education and more. Lapidary classes, music classes and a leather crafts class are also offered.

A class on how to cope with sight loss is offered to the adults, because sight loss late in life can be frightening, Olsen said. Losing the ability to drive or read the newspaper every day will change a person's entire lifestyle. There is also a class offered for the significant others of the adult campers, designed to teach them how to be supportive, Olsen said.

Lions Milk Camp

In 1926 many Casper children were underfed due to a lack of jobs in the community. The Lions Club of Casper opened their first camp at the base of Casper Mountain for undernourished children that year, earning the name "Lions' Milk Camp." In 1928 the camp was moved to the present site and was a refuge for undernourished children until World War II, when it was discontinued.

Smith Shumway, a native of Cheyenne, lost his sight on Normandy Beach in World War II. Upon returning to Wyoming, Shumway approached the Casper Lions Club to present the idea of reopening the camp for the visually impaired. The first camp for the blind was held in the summer of 1946.

Prior to 1979, the camp was solely funded by the Lions Clubs of Wyoming. In 1979, the camp officially became a state project through the Department of Education. The Lions Club now leases the camp site to the Allen H. Stewart Blind Camp, which is run by a board of directors.

Skills for Life

Thirteen-year-old Michael Hernandez from Cheyenne has been attending the camp for five years. This year, he learned to fry an egg and prepare his own breakfast. Hernandez has albinism, or a lack of melanin in his skin, hair and eyes. Albinism is often associated with sight problems or sensitivity to light.

"It is something I have had since birth," Hernandez said. Hernandez explained that he has limited sight but can read. There are bifocals in his glasses and he said he has to "get closer to things than other kids" to see them.

Hernandez loves coming to the camp because it is a place where he can learn and be around other children with similar conditions, he said.

"We want the kids to learn to overcome difficult situations," Olsen said. "They learn skills they can take with them to their communities."

For Chad Langley, the camp has become a mainstay in his summer plans. Langley, who was born blind with cataracts, has been teaching computer skills for three years at the camp. Langley had surgery as a child to remove the cataracts and is no longer legally blind, but still experiences some visual impairments.

Langley teaches the campers to use adaptive software to learn basic key boarding skills, basic Windows skills and some networking skills.

"I let them play games, too, but only on breaks," Langley smiled. "If the students learn young in life, that will help them later on."

Langley began attending the camp at age nine. He now attends Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University in Prescott, Ariz., where he studies aerospace engineering and software engineering. One of his dreams is to work for NASA designing space crafts.

"I never let my visual impairments hold me back," Langley said. "I have always just found my own way to do things."

Forming friendships

As the campers were organized into a game of tee-ball, 9-year-old Kaitlin Slagle and 12-year-old Emma Elwell held hands, hoping to be on the same team.

"We're best friends," Elwell, who lives in Laramie, said, as she hugged her friend's arm. "We met last year and we only see each other at camp."

Elwell has strabismus, or has crossed eyes, and Slagle has albinism.

"We were excited to see each other all year," Slagle, who lives in Casper, said. "We took pictures of each other last year to keep."

Camp is a special place for the kids, Olsen said.

"Sometimes, kids who are visually impaired are not accepted by their peers for whatever reason," Olsen said. "Some of the friendships made here become life-long. They don't have to struggle to be accepted here."

Even for the older campers, camp is a place for socializing. According to Olsen, most of the adult campers are senior citizens experiencing macular degeneration, a disease which causes degeneration of the retina resulting in decreased central vision or blindness.

"For people who have been sighted their whole lives, it is difficult to not be able to recognize people anymore," Olsen said.

Chelsey Dodge,16, is in her second year as an intern at the camp and eighth year attending camp. Dodge has aniridia, or an absence of the iris causing impaired vision.

"It is so peaceful up here. I love it, and I get to see the kids," Dodge said. "This is so important to them. Here, they know that they are not the only ones out there."

By Carrie May, Star-Tribune staff writer
Casper Star Tribune
Staff writer Carrie May can be reached at 266-0616 or caroline.may@casperstartribune.net.
http://www.casperstartribune.net/articles/2005/07/18/news/
casper/613600f4aad30d1087257040000430d2.txt


'Each of our children is different'

Billie-Jo Bailey is a happy friendly child who has lots of friends and enjoys school.

For her family these are the important facts - that she also has Down's Syndrome is a secondary consideration.

Many people meeting her for the first time, however, tend to focus on her Down's first and foremost.

But as her father Richard explains Down's Syndrome is just a part of Billie-Jo, not the whole.

Different

And this is why he and a group of other professional photographers, all of whose children have Down's Syndrome, decided to photograph them and others to show that each child is different.

And the results are a fantastic insight into Down's and the very different lives of the children with it.

Richard admits that before Billie-Jo's birth, he too had preconceived ideas.

"When she was born we had an image of Down's which was from people we saw when we were growing up.

"But all the children we met when we were taking the photographs were very different. They were more like their parents than 'Mr and Mrs Downs'.

"We just wanted to show how different all these kids were."

He said that although some children have heart problems and that this had initially worried them about Billie-Jo, she is a very healthy little girl and despite needing speech and language therapy is in a mainstream school.

"She is fantastic. She has all her little friends over from school for sleep-overs and she goes to stay with them. It is all pretty ordinary."

Richard said that taking the pictures for the exhibition - which are made up of portraits as well as the 365 head and shoulder shots - had allowed them to meet other parents and that some of them said they were still facing a lot of stigma and ignorance.

"One man had taken his son swimming and someone said to him 'Is it contagious'.

"They were obviously very ignorant, but people do have this stereotype that they all live in a home and are overweight with their tongues hanging out all the time."

Exhibition

He said the response to the exhibition 'Shifting Perspectives', which has been on display in the Oxo tower and attracted about 1,500 visitors and is now on permanent display at the Down's Syndrome Association (DSA), had been tremendous.

Each child was photographed in the same black t-shirt to ensure that the focus remains on them, rather than on anything they are wearing.

He said many people had commented to both himself and the other photographers that it had helped change their perspectives.

"It has been absolutely incredible and has really taken off."

Liz Marder, paediatrician and medical adviser to the DSA, said medics are constantly trying to re-educate parents of newly diagnosed children about what to expect.

She said that much of the literature on Down's was out-dated and very 'pessimistic' and that she tried to give parents a more modern prognosis.

"We tell them that the children are all very different and very individual."

And she praised the exhibition for trying to correct many myths.

"I think it helps people put things into perspective. For instance only about half of children will have heart problems and they can vary from something that goes away by itself to something that can be life threatening."

A spokesperson for the Down's Syndrome Association said an exhibition like this has done much to change perceptions and right myths.

"Following the closure of long-stay institutions and now with the inclusion of children with Down's syndrome in mainstream schools, society's perceptions of people with Down's syndrome are improving year on year.

"However, positive images are still all too rare in the arts and the media.

"The 'Shifting Perspectives' exhibition makes it immediately obvious that the old prejudices about people with Down's syndrome such as "they all look the same" are utterly inappropriate.

The individuality, personality and humanity of every single child and adult pictured come across loud and clear."


Down's Syndrome

Around one in every 1000 babies born in the UK will have Down's
syndrome. (One to two babies are born with Down's syndrome every day in the UK alone)

There are 60,000 people in the UK with the condition

Although the chance of having a baby with Down's syndrome is higher for older mothers, more babies with Down's syndrome are born to younger women.

Down's syndrome is caused by the presence of an extra chromosome in a baby's cells. It occurs by chance at conception and is irreversible.

By Jane Elliott
BBC News health reporter
BBC NEWS:
July 16, 2005
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/health/4685639.stm


Video games have therapeutic potential -expert

LONDON (Reuters) - Parents take note -- video games are not all bad.

In young children and adolescents they can lead to excessive use and aggressive behavior but a leading expert said Friday that the games ease pain, distract patients undergoing chemotherapy for cancer and help to develop dexterity.

"The degree of attention needed to play such a game can distract the player from the sensation of pain," Professor Mark Griffiths, of Nottingham University in England, said in an editorial in the British Medical Journal.

In patients with arm injuries, the games have been used to increase strength and dexterity while children with learning disabilities have played them to develop spatial ability.

"Therapeutic benefits have also been reported for a variety of adult populations including wheelchair users with spinal cord injuries, people with severe burns and people with muscular dystrophy," according to Griffiths.

Although the reported negative effects, which include wrist pain, hallucinations and repetitive strain injuries, have been widely reported, Griffiths said they tend to be temporary and could be caused by other factors.

"Some of these adverse effects seem to be rare and many resolve when the patients no long play the games," he added.

Griffiths, a professor of gambling studies, called for more studies into the long-term effects of video games and what constitutes excessive use.

"Further research should examine factors within games such as novelty, users' preferences, and relative levels of challenge and should compare video games with other potentially distracting activities," he added.

Reuters
http://today.reuters.com/News/newsArticle.aspx?type=healthNews&storyID=
2005-07-14T230615Z_01_L14175655_RTRIDST_0_HEALTH-HEALTH-
VIDEOGAMES-DC.XML

Friday, July 01, 2005

JULY 2005

Crickets offer hope to deaf

Super-sensitive sound detectors used by crickets to spot predators have been recreated in the laboratory, it was revealed today.

Scientists hope studying the tiny artificial hairs might lead to the development of new cochlea implants for deaf people.

The sensors will also have a range of other research applications, such as measuring airflows over aircraft.

Crickets spend most of their lives on the ground, making them vulnerable to predators such as wasps and spiders.

Species like the wood cricket have developed a pair of hairy appendages on their abdomens called cerci which can detect the smallest fluctuations in air currents.

Each of the hairs is lodged in a socket. Air vibrations drag on the hair, rotating its base and triggering specific nerve cells.

The nerve messages allow the cricket to pinpoint low-frequency sound from any direction with incredible sensitivity.

Crickets use their cerci to detect and escape from attacking predators.

Physicists at the University of Twente in the Netherlands built their own version of the system with up to a few hundred artificial hairs, the Journal of Micromechanics and Microengineering reported.

The fine plastic hairs are attached to membranes with built-in electrodes and capacitors. Airflow on the hair causes an electrical change which sends out a signal in a similar fashion to the cricket's cerci.

Dr Marcel Dijkstra, a member of the team, said: "These sensors are the first step towards a variety of exciting applications as well as further scientific exploration.

"Their small size and low energy consumption make them excellent for application in large sensor networks. We could use them to visualise airflow on surfaces, such as an aircraft fuselage."

In the more distant future the scientists hope the structures might lead to more sophisticated and efficient cochlea implants.

Hearing is made possible by tiny hairs disturbed by liquid in the cochlea of the inner ear.

If the sensitive hairs are destroyed they cannot send out nerve messages in response to sound, and deafness results.

The Daily Mail - Health Section
June 21, 2005
©2005 Associated New Media
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/health/
healthmain.html?in_article_id=353046&in_page_id=1774


Braille, Computers And Paws
Blind Valedictorian Has The World At Her Fingertips

Courtney Tabor has a computer screen glaring from the corner of her bedroom with the instant messenger ready to be signed on. A monotone voice from the speakers tells Tabor when her friends come online.

When she was younger, Tabor could see the screen if she set everything to a black background with 72-point white letters.

Today, Tabor, 18, uses her fingertips as eyes.

The RHAM school district provided her with the $6,000 computer called a Braille Note to type papers, read books and go online, said Interim Superintendent Brian Morin, who is also director of special education.

"We went aggressively because of Courtney's ability," Morin said. "We knew that she would soar."

And soar she did. Tabor is the RHAM High School valedictorian. When she gives her speech at commencement June 22, her graduation gift will be by her side - a Fidelco guide dog named Meeka.

"My goal when I got Meeka was that I wanted to have independence," said Tabor, of Hebron. "I used to need someone to help me up."

Before Meeka, Tabor walked with a white cane or latched on to the elbow of a sighted person to climb stairs.

The German shepherd, which Tabor has trained for graduation since April, will march beside her in a dog-sized cap and gown.

As Tabor enters the collegiate world, devoid of microwaves with Braille on the popcorn button like she has at home, she will have to rely on Meeka to guide her though the independent life she craves.

Tabor has Leber's Congenital Amaurosis, an incurable retinal disease that causes childhood blindness.

With her left eye, Tabor can detect the difference between light and dark. The sight in her right eye disappeared suddenly last summer when the normal pressure in her eye doubled.

Her doctor cut small holes into her iris with a laser to alleviate the searing pain behind her eye, but Tabor said the discomfort returned. Her final option was to have the entire lens removed.

"It was kind of scary because it came with a lot of pain, too," she said as her mother, Marie Tabor, waved a hand in front of her daughter's face to demonstrate that her left eye can sense only shadows. "Now I really can't see because there is no lens to focus the light," Courtney Tabor said.

Tabor knows that one day her eyesight may disappear entirely, but she doesn't worry about that possibility.

"I can't look at it as a big deal or I'd be a depressed person," she said.

For the Tabor family, this outlook is vital.

Tabor's 13-year-old brother Eddie also has Leber's Congenital Amaurosis. Tabor said it is Eddie who brings humor to the family.

"Eddie get that off my face," Marie Tabor said after he enlarged her face on a giant screen with his Clarity Deskmate, a video magnifier that displays images on a 15-inch monitor.

Even though Courtney Tabor could not see the camera moving toward her face next, she knew it was coming.

She expects taunts and tricks from Eddie, such as closing doors in their home so she walks into them. Eddie calls her blindette, puts rubber spiders under her pillow and lives through the voices of characters from "Master of Disguise."

Before Eddie was born, Marie Tabor said she knew there was a one in four chance that her son would have Leber's.

"Oh gosh it was definitely something you think about but I wanted her to have a sibling," Marie Tabor said. "We didn't think the odds were against us."

Eddie is able to faintly see things for Tabor when it is not too dark or bright out.

"I'll tend to describe movies to [Courtney] the best I can so we can both get a little bit out of it," said Eddie, who focuses his Deskmate on the TV or sits right in front of the screen so he can see.

Tabor said that in place of her sight, she has adapted to using her acute sense of touch and hearing, which is "great for eavesdropping."

She pats the partition between the kitchen and living room that she constantly bumps into and jokes about her own clumsiness.

"I knocked over the Christmas tree, too," she said.

Tabor taps on the Braille Note's nine keys, occasionally running her fingertips over the 32-letter Braille display to edit what she has written or reread a sentence in a book.

Homework takes Tabor two to three times longer than a sighted student.

"You can't skim," she said. "There's no highlighting. If you have to go back to the reading you can't automatically find your spot."

Despite the time constraint, Tabor takes a "normal course load" of four honors classes, three of which are advanced placement courses, one after-school honors class and, her favorite subject, choir.

"I cannot pop for the life of me," she said as she and members of Encore, RHAM's female choir, who were popping their lips while rehearsing the song "Lollipop," gathered around the piano.

While most of the other girls held sheet music in their hands, Tabor held onto Meeka's leash.

Occasionally, Tabor stops singing to whisper "lay down" to Meeka, who sniffs the other singers.

Tabor is headed to Middlebury College in Vermont, where she plans to study foreign languages.

"I'm just so done with high school," she said. "I'm ready to have a different kind of lifestyle and be on my own."

But independence can be limiting.

The 50-volume Braille English textbooks and 30-volume psychology books on tape, which clutter the floor by her desk, will be harder to find at the college level, she said.

Instead of working at her own pace and having the freedom to look back in a novel for that perfect quote, Tabor will have some texts recited by a reader.

"It will eliminate your independence to do it when you want to do it," Marie Tabor said to her daughter in her office at RHAM High School, which is lined with volumes of white Braille texts.

As the RHAM Brailleist, Marie Tabor converts her children's tests and worksheets into Braille and orders their Braille books or books on tape. In college, Courtney Tabor will not have a Brailleist, but will have to rely more on a reader.

But Tabor said she is excited to meet her reader, who she hopes will become a close friend.

"People need to realize that every single person you meet has to do with something you are," she said, referring to what may be the theme of her valedictorian speech. "Even a smile when someone passes by."

Her own path to college was influenced by volunteer work with special-needs students and correspondence with English-as-a-second language students from Hartford as part of RHAM's sister school project, she said.

"I love that idea of being able to speak to someone you don't necessarily understand at first," she said. "Just learning English is like being close minded."

If scientists can eventually restore her vision, she isn't sure she would want it.

"I was born with this," she said. "Do I really need anything more than I have now? This is what God gave me."

By Brittany Oat
Courant Staff Writer
June 20, 2005
Copyright 2005 Hartford Courant Connecticut News http://www.courant.com/news/local/hc-rhamblind0620.artjun20,0,7807004.story?
page=3&coll=hc-headlines-local



On Autism's Cause, It's Parents vs. Research

Kristen Ehresmann, a Minnesota Department of Health official, had just told a State Senate hearing that vaccines with microscopic amounts of mercury were safe. Libby Rupp, a mother of a 3-year-old girl with autism, was incredulous.

"How did my daughter get so much mercury in her?" Ms. Rupp asked Ms. Ehresmann after her testimony.

"Fish?" Ms. Ehresmann suggested.

"She never eats it," Ms. Rupp answered.

"Do you drink tap water?"

"It's all filtered."

"Well, do you breathe the air?" Ms. Ehresmann asked, with a resigned smile. Several parents looked angrily at Ms. Ehresmann, who left.

Ms. Rupp remained, shaking with anger. That anyone could defend mercury in vaccines, she said, "makes my blood boil."

Public health officials like Ms. Ehresmann, who herself has a son with autism, have been trying for years to convince parents like Ms. Rupp that there is no link between thimerosal - a mercury-containing preservative once used routinely in vaccines - and autism.

They have failed.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Food and Drug Administration, the Institute of Medicine, the World Health Organization and the American Academy of Pediatrics have all largely dismissed the notion that thimerosal causes or contributes to autism. Five major studies have found no link.

Yet despite all evidence to the contrary, the number of parents who blame thimerosal for their children's autism has only increased. And in recent months, these parents have used their numbers, their passion and their organizing skills to become a potent national force. The issue has become one of the most fractious and divisive in pediatric medicine.

"This is like nothing I've ever seen before," Dr. Melinda Wharton, deputy director of the National Immunization Program, told a gathering of immunization officials in Washington in March. "It's an era where it appears that science isn't enough."

Parents have filed more than 4,800 lawsuits - 200 from February to April alone - pushed for state and federal legislation banning thimerosal and taken out full-page advertisements in major newspapers. They have also gained the support of politicians, including Senator Joseph I. Lieberman, Democrat of Connecticut, and Representatives Dan Burton, Republican of Indiana, and Dave Weldon, Republican of Florida. And Robert F. Kennedy Jr. wrote an article in the June 16 issue of Rolling Stone magazine arguing that most studies of the issue are flawed and that public health officials are conspiring with drug makers to cover up the damage caused by thimerosal.

"We're not looking like a fringe group anymore," said Becky Lourey, a Minnesota state senator and a sponsor of a proposed thimerosal ban. Such a ban passed the New York State Legislature this week.

But scientists and public health officials say they are alarmed by the surge of attention to an idea without scientific merit. The anti-thimerosal campaign, they say, is causing some parents to stay away from vaccines, placing their children at risk for illnesses like measles and polio.

"It's really terrifying, the scientific illiteracy that supports these suspicions," said Dr. Marie McCormick, chairwoman of an Institute of Medicine panel that examined the controversy in February 2004.

Experts say they are also concerned about a raft of unproven, costly and potentially harmful treatments - including strict diets, supplements and a detoxifying technique called chelation - that are being sold for tens of thousands of dollars to desperate parents of autistic children as a cure for "mercury poisoning."

In one case, a doctor forced children to sit in a 160-degree sauna, swallow 60 to 70 supplements a day and have so much blood drawn that one child passed out.

Hundreds of doctors list their names on a Web site endorsing chelation to treat autism, even though experts say that no evidence supports its use with that disorder. The treatment carries risks of liver and kidney damage, skin rashes and nutritional deficiencies, they say.

In recent months, the fight over thimerosal has become even more bitter. In response to a barrage of threatening letters and phone calls, the centers for disease control has increased security and instructed employees on safety issues, including how to respond if pies are thrown in their faces. One vaccine expert at the centers wrote in an internal e-mail message that she felt safer working at a malaria field station in Kenya than she did at the agency's offices in Atlanta.

An Alarm is Sounded

Thimerosal was for decades the favored preservative for use in vaccines. By weight, it is about 50 percent ethyl mercury, a form of mercury most scientists consider to be less toxic than methyl mercury, the type found in fish. The amount of ethyl mercury included in each childhood vaccine was once roughly equal to the amount of methyl mercury found in the average tuna sandwich.

In 1999, a Food and Drug Administration scientist added up all the mercury that American infants got with a full immunization schedule and concluded that the amount exceeded a government guideline. Some health authorities counseled no action, because there was no evidence that thimerosal at the doses given was harmful and removing it might cause alarm. Others were not so certain that thimerosal was harmless.

In July 1999, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Public Health Service released a joint statement urging vaccine makers to remove thimerosal as quickly as possible. By 2001, no vaccine routinely administered to children in the United States had more than half of a microgram of mercury - about what is found in an infant's daily supply of breast milk.

Despite the change, government agencies say that vaccines with thimerosal are just as safe as those without, and adult flu vaccines still contain the preservative.

But the 1999 advisory alarmed many parents whose children suffered from autism, a lifelong disorder marked by repetitive, sometimes self-destructive behaviors and an inability to form social relationships. In 10 to 25 percent of cases, autism seems to descend on young children seemingly overnight, sometime between their first and second birthdays.

Diagnoses of autism have risen sharply in recent years, from roughly 1 case for every 10,000 births in the 1980's to 1 in 166 births in 2003.

Most scientists believe that the illness is influenced strongly by genetics but that some unknown environmental factor may also play a role.

Dr. Tom Insel, director of the National Institute for Mental Health, said: "Is it cellphones? Ultrasound? Diet sodas? Every parent has a theory. At this point, we just don't know."

In 2000, a group of parents joined together to found SafeMinds, one of several organizations that argue that thimerosal is that environmental culprit. Their cause has been championed by politicians like Mr. Burton.

"My grandson received nine shots in one day, seven of which contained thimerosal, which is 50 percent mercury as you know, and he became autistic a short time later," he said in an interview.

In a series of House hearings held from 2000 through 2004, Mr. Burton called the leading experts who assert that vaccines cause autism to testify. They included a chemistry professor at the University of Kentucky who says that dental fillings cause or exacerbate autism and other diseases and a doctor from Baton Rouge, La., who says that God spoke to her through an 87-year-old priest and told her that vaccines caused autism.

Also testifying were Dr. Mark Geier and his son, David Geier, the experts whose work is most frequently cited by parents.

Trying to Build a Case

Dr. Geier has called the use of thimerosal in vaccines the world's "greatest catastrophe that's ever happened, regardless of cause."

He and his son live and work in a two-story house in suburban Maryland. Past the kitchen and down the stairs is a room with cast-off, unplugged laboratory equipment, wall-to-wall carpeting and faux wood paneling that Dr. Geier calls "a world-class lab - every bit as good as anything at N.I.H."

Dr. Geier has been examining issues of vaccine safety since at least 1971, when he was a lab assistant at the National Institutes of Health, or N.I.H. His résumé lists scores of publications, many of which suggest that vaccines cause injury or disease.

He has also testified in more than 90 vaccine cases, he said, although a judge in a vaccine case in 2003 ruled that Dr. Geier was "a professional witness in areas for which he has no training, expertise and experience."

In other cases, judges have called Dr. Geier's testimony "intellectually dishonest," "not reliable" and "wholly unqualified."

The six published studies by Dr. Geier and David Geier on the relationship between autism and thimerosal are largely based on complaints sent to the disease control centers by people who suspect that their children were harmed by vaccines.

In the first study, the Geiers compared the number of complaints associated with a thimerosal-containing vaccine, given from 1992 to 2000, with the complaints that resulted from a thimerosal-free version given from 1997 to 2000. The more thimerosal a child received, they concluded, the more likely an autism complaint was filed. Four other studies used similar methods and came to similar conclusions.

Dr. Geier said in an interview that the link between thimerosal and autism was clear.

Public health officials, he said, are " just trying to cover it up."

Assessing the Studies

Scientists say that the Geiers' studies are tainted by faulty methodology.

"The problem with the Geiers' research is that they start with the answers and work backwards," said Dr. Steven Black, director of the Kaiser Permanente Vaccine Study Center in Oakland, Calif. "They are doing voodoo science."

Dr. Julie L. Gerberding, the director of the disease control centers, said the agency was not withholding information about any potentially damaging effects of thimerosal.

"There's certainly not a conspiracy here," she said. "And we would never consider not acknowledging information or evidence that would have a bearing on children's health."

In 2003, spurred by parents' demands, the C.D.C. asked the Institute of Medicine, an arm of the National Academy of Sciences and the nation's most prestigious medical advisory group, to review the evidence on thimerosal and autism.

In a report last year, a panel convened by the institute dismissed the Geiers' work as having such serious flaws that their studies were "uninterpretable." Some of the Geiers' mathematical formulas, the committee found, "provided no information," and the Geiers used basic scientific terms like "attributable risk" incorrectly.

In contrast, the committee found five studies that examined hundreds of thousands of health records of children in the United States, Britain, Denmark and Sweden to be persuasive.

A study by the World Health Organization, for example, examined the health records of 109,863 children born in Britain from 1988 to 1997 and found that children who had received the most thimerosal in vaccines had the lowest incidence of developmental problems like autism.

Another study examined the records of 467,450 Danish children born from 1990 to 1996. It found that after 1992, when the country's only thimerosal-containing vaccine was replaced by one free of the preservative, autism rates rose rather than fell.

In one of the most comprehensive studies, a 2003 report by C.D.C. scientists examined the medical records of more than 125,000 children born in the United States from 1991 to 1999. It found no difference in autism rates among children exposed to various amounts of thimerosal.

Parent groups, led by SafeMinds, replied that documents obtained from the disease control centers showed that early versions of the study had found a link between thimerosal and autism.

But C.D.C. researchers said that it was not unusual for studies to evolve as more data and controls were added. The early versions of the study, they said, failed to control for factors like low birth weight, which increases the risk of developmental delays.

The Institute of Medicine said that it saw "nothing inherently troubling" with the C.D.C.'s adjustments and concluded that thimerosal did not cause autism. Further studies, the institute said, would not be "useful."

Threats and Conspiracy Talk

Since the report's release, scientists and health officials have been bombarded with hostile e-mail messages and phone calls. Dr. McCormick, the chairwoman of the institute's panel, said she had received threatening mail claiming that she was part of a conspiracy. Harvard University has increased security at her office, she said.

An e-mail message to the C.D.C. on Nov. 28 stated, "Forgiveness is between them and God. It is my job to arrange a meeting," according to records obtained by The New York Times after the filing of an open records request.

Another e-mail message, sent to the C.D.C. on Aug. 20, said, "I'd like to know how you people sleep straight in bed at night knowing all the lies you tell & the lives you know full well you destroy with the poisons you push & protect with your lies." Lynn Redwood of SafeMinds said that such e-mail messages did not represent her organization or other advocacy groups.

In response to the threats, C.D.C. officials have contacted the Federal Bureau of Investigation and heightened security at the disease control centers. Some officials said that the threats had led them to look for other jobs.

In "Evidence of Harm," a book published earlier this year that is sympathetic to the notion that thimerosal causes autism, the author, David Kirby, wrote that the thimerosal theory would stand or fall within the next year or two.

Because autism is usually diagnosed sometime between a child's third and fourth birthdays and thimerosal was largely removed from childhood vaccines in 2001, the incidence of autism should fall this year, he said.

No such decline followed thimerosal's removal from vaccines during the 1990's in Denmark, Sweden or Canada, researchers say.

But the debate over autism and vaccines is not likely to end soon.

"It doesn't seem to matter what the studies and the data show," said Ms. Ehresmann, the Minnesota immunization official. "And that's really scary for us because if science doesn't count, how do we make decisions? How do we communicate with parents?"

Gardiner Harris and Anahad O'Connor
June 25, 2005
The New York Times
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/25/science/25autism.html?pagewanted=1


To Vaccinate or Not? Sorting Out the Confusion Over Meningitis Shots

With summer closing in fast, Julie Kern was eager to squeeze in a routine medical checkup for her 12-year-old daughter before she headed off to camp in Massachusetts.

But then the pediatrician surprised Ms. Kern. "The doctor said that if my daughter was planning to attend sleep-away camp, it was 'mandated by law' - those were the words she used - that she receive a meningitis vaccine," said Ms. Kern, who lives in New York.

The doctor was wrong. There are no regulations - local, state or federal - that require campers to be vaccinated against meningococcal bacteria, a source of rare but fierce blood and spinal infections that can maim or kill previously healthy people within hours.

Nevertheless, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention would agree with Ms. Kern's pediatrician that her daughter should get the shot - not because she is going to camp, but because of her age.

In late May, the health authorities urged doctors to start giving a newly available, longer-lasting meningococcal vaccine to children at age 11 or 12. The policy shift was intended to have young adolescents immunized just before their risk of catching a deadly form of meningitis begins to climb.

The new vaccine, from Sanofi Pasteur, is called Menactra and was approved in January by the Food and Drug Administration for use in people from ages 11 to 55.

One shot of Menactra is expected to increase immunity against four of the five deadliest strains of meningococcal bacteria for at least 8 to 10 years. That's twice as long as the protection provided by an earlier vaccine, Menomune, made by the same company.

Unlike the older vaccine, Menactra also quells silent meningococcal infections among asymptomatic carriers, who manage to escape the microbe's treachery, only to pass the infection along to someone more susceptible through a kiss, a wayward cough or a shared glass or fork.

Nancy Ford Springer's son contracted invasive meningococcal disease six years ago, when he was 14.

"My son, Nick, was a healthy, handsome boy, and thank goodness he is once again healthy and handsome, but he lost both his hands and both his legs to this disease," said Ms. Ford Springer, who lives in Westchester County and is a co-founder of the National Meningitis Association, a nonprofit support and education group.

"We were the lucky ones," she said. "Nick's still alive."

Meningitis, an inflammation of the membranes encasing the brain and spinal cord, is just one manifestation of meningococcal disease, which afflicts as many as 2,800 people in the United States every year, according to the disease control agency. Of those, about 300 die rapidly; another 400 lose limbs, suffer brain or kidney damage, become deaf or suffer other permanent disabilities.

The disease can strike at any age, but in the United States, infants and young people from 15 to 20 are hardest hit.

The Food and Drug Administration has not yet approved a vaccine against serogroup B meningococcal, the strain that most frequently afflicts babies. But Menactra, like Menomune, does work against A, C, Y and W-135, the strains that account for 75 percent of serious infections in teenagers.

"When you start reading about these cases, our stories are all the same: rapid, tragic and deadly, with children who are healthy one day and on death's door the next," Ms. Ford Springer said.

Three epidemiological studies show that among teenagers, the highest incidence of the invasive form of the disease occurs among college freshmen living in dorms.

The finding suggests an emerging, if still murky, risk profile: young people who are suddenly living in close quarters, perhaps with the added stress of little sleep, frequent colds and exposure to cigarette smoke.

"We would love nothing more than to give this vaccine to everyone between the ages of 11 and 23, or even beyond that," said Sarah Long, chief of infectious diseases at St. Christopher's Hospital for Children in Philadelphia and a member of the American Academy of Pediatrics committee that reviewed the data. "It's a very good vaccine."

But a limited supply of Menactra, and its relatively high price - $80 to $100 or more per shot - have prompted a more patchwork approach.

The pediatrics academy and the C.D.C. hope that within three years the vaccine's maker, state health departments and private insurers will be able to ensure that every 11-year-old can get the vaccine at a checkup that will likely include other immunizations and health advice.

In the meantime, to catch those teenagers most at risk now, the health officials also recommend the vaccine for 15-year-olds entering high school, military recruits and college freshmen living in dormitories. Rounding out the list are people in countries like those of sub-Saharan Africa where the disease is endemic, lab scientists who work with the bacteria and people without spleens or with certain other ailments, as well as adolescents who wish to reduce their risk.

Legislatures in New York and Massachusetts have passed laws requiring camps to educate parents about the risks of meningococcal disease and about the existence of a vaccine against it. New York also requires a written waiver from parents who choose not to have their children vaccinated. Menactra is so new that many of the letters that went out this summer describe the older vaccine.

These laws may be what confused Ms. Kern and her doctor.

But Ms. Ford Springer thinks that at least in principle such letters are needed. "I definitely wish we'd known more about this disease," she said. "We would have vaccinated Nick."

By DEBORAH FRANKLIN
The New York Times
June 28, 2005
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/28/health/policy/28cons.html


Special education helps all students

The University of Cincinnati has just announced a plan to offer free or drastically reduced tuition to teachers willing to enter the field of special education.

That's a cost savings and employment enhancement for teachers, but the real winners in this package are students - and that's not just children with special needs but regular education students as well.

The newly recertified teachers will serve as intervention specialists, which means they'll work in regular classrooms that have some students with special needs.

Working in conjunction with the regular classroom teacher, these specialists can make an amazing difference for kids. Their presence means individualized support for special-needs students, thereby allowing the teacher to better concentrate on the overall needs of the group.

But the specialist's efforts quickly spread to the entire classroom. As they work to help disabled students work collaboratively with other students, they often offer the kind of support and instruction that benefits typical students as well. The extra attention is powerful, and their instructional skills - reframing the lesson, for example, or suggesting other approaches to solving a problem - are helpful to all students.

Their greatest contribution, however, may be removing the stigma from getting extra help when you need it. Often, students never realize exactly why an intervention specialist is in their classroom, or which students he or she is there to help.

As opposed to past days, where special education students were educated in separate classrooms or pulled out of their regular classrooms for help, the entry of an intervention specialist into the classroom supports a climate of inclusion.

The UC plan will pay full tuition costs for 25 teachers to be recertified in special education; it will provide lower tuition rates for an additional 35.

UC won a $200,000 grant from the Ohio Department of Education to fund the one-year program, which will recruit candidates throughout Southwestern Ohio. Kentucky teachers can apply for the reduced tuition option, but not the free tuition plan.

The grant is an attempt to increase the number of certified teachers in an area with chronic shortages.

For more information on the UC tuition program, check the Web site of the College of Education, Criminal Justice and Human Service at www.education.uc.edu, or call Anne Bauer, professor of teacher education, at (513) 556-4537.

The Enquirer - Editorial
Monday, June 27, 2005
http://news.enquirer.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050627/EDIT01/506270301/1020/EDIT


New computer software for people with learning disabilities to be unveiled at open morning

New computer software to teach people with learning disabilities the basic skills needed for everyday activities like shopping and crossing roads has been developed by researchers at The University of Nottingham.

Using a specially adapted joystick and the click of a mouse, people with learning disabilities can put money into a trolley, navigate themselves around a three-dimensional computer-generated supermarket and find items they need on their shopping list.

In another 3-D street scene program they can practise crossing the road in a number of different scenarios, including using a zebra crossing, a pelican crossing and safely crossing without help near a crossroads.

A computer game dubbed ’Running Man’ has been written, in which users need to move a character across a two-dimensional screen, using a switch to make the character jump obstacles.

The software, which will be on display at an open morning being held in Bilborough later this week, has been developed by a team led by Professor Penny Standen in the University’s Division of Rehabilitation and Ageing, and computer scientist David Brown at Nottingham Trent University. It aims to make computers easier to use for people with learning disabilities who may also have some physical impairment, teach them new social and health and safety skills and develop cognitive abilities such as reaction time and attention span.

The research has been funded by grants from organisations including the Economics and Social Sciences Research Council (ESRC), the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC), the European Social Fund and the Learning Skills Council.

Professor Standen said: “For many of us activities like going to the shops or crossing the road are very simple tasks that we wouldn’t think twice about. However, for someone who has severe learning disabilities, which may include a limited use of language, and, in some cases, some form of physical impairment, it can be quite a daunting experience.

“Our studies have shown that through the use of this new software, the skills and abilities of the people with learning disabilities who worked with us on this research did improve. The software provides activities that are educational but also fun, therapeutic and stimulating.”

Innovation Report
June 21, 2005
http://www.innovations-report.com/html/reports/information_technology/report-45629.html


Taught at Home, but Seeking to Join Activities
at Public Schools

STRASBURG, Pa., June 16 - Mary Mellinger began home-schooling her eldest sons, Andrew and Abram, on the family's 80-acre dairy farm five years ago, wanting them to spend more time with their father and receive an education infused with Christian principles. Home schooling could not, however, provide one thing the boys desperately wanted - athletic competition.

But the school district here, about 60 miles west of Philadelphia, does not allow home-schooled children to play on its teams. So Mrs. Mellinger reluctantly gave in and allowed the boys to enroll in public high school, where Andrew, 17, runs track and Abram, 15, plays football and both perform with the marching and concert bands.

"We grieved about losing the time we had with the boys," Mrs. Mellinger, 41, said outside the 150-year-old red brick house where Mellingers have lived for seven generations. "It seems so unfair. We're taxpayers, too."

Mrs. Mellinger's plaint has become the rallying cry for an increasing number of parents across the country who are pushing more public schools to open their sports teams, clubs, music groups and other extracurricular organizations to the nation's more than 1 million home-educated students.

This year, bills were introduced in at least 14 state legislatures, including Pennsylvania's, to require school districts to open extracurricular activities, and sometimes classes, to home-schooled children, say groups that track the issue. Fourteen states already require such access, while most others leave the decision to local school boards.

But many districts strongly resist the idea, citing inadequate resources, liability issues, questions about whether students would be displaced from teams and clubs, and concerns about whether home-schooled children could be held to the same academic and attendance standards. In some states, districts also lose state aid when children leave to be home schooled, although that is not the case in Pennsylvania.

The push for access is in many ways a new chapter for the home-schooling movement, which for years viewed public education as a hostile, overly regulated system that should be avoided at all costs.

But as the movement has gained more acceptance and grown in size and diversity, more parents want their children to be involved in school activities like chess, basketball or Advanced Placement courses, say home-schooling advocates and educators. Even people who do not want the services argue that other families should not be denied them, seeing access as a civil rights issue for people who pay school taxes.

"We found enough activities within the home-school community to satisfy our needs," said Maryalice Newborn, who runs a support network for home-school families outside Pittsburgh. "But if somebody else wants to participate, shouldn't they have that right?"

Christopher Klicka, senior counsel for the Home School Legal Defense Association, a nonprofit group based in Virginia, said polls showed that a majority of home-school parents remained wary of letting their children participate in public school activities. But as earlier battles over the right to home schooling fade from memory, that attitude is likely to change, he said.

"The further we get from those early days, when there was real persecution, the more people will forget," Mr. Klicka said. "And they will want equal access more."

In Oregon, Colorado and other states that distribute aid based on enrollment, some districts have begun encouraging home-schooled students to take courses, typically in advanced subjects like calculus or foreign languages, said Mike Griffith, a policy analyst with the Education Commission of the States, a nonprofit group.

But most states do not provide per-pupil aid for extracurricular activities, so there is less incentive to allow home-schooled students to participate, Mr. Griffith said.

In Pennsylvania, where the number of home-schooled students has risen steadily in recent years to more than 24,400 children, more districts each year are allowing those students to participate in extracurricular activities, and sometimes classes.

But nearly half of the state's 501 school districts prohibit such access, including many here in rural Lancaster County, a conservative area with one of the largest populations of home-schooled students in the state. Stephany Baughman of Strasburg led the fight to change that policy in one of the districts last year.

Mrs. Baughman has always home-schooled her four children, calling it a way "to speak into their lives." But two years ago, her eldest child, Derek, wanted to join the high school soccer team. The Lampeter-Strasburg district said no. So she petitioned the school board last year to change its policy, turning the drive into a civics lesson for her children.

The board refused to change its policy. So she sent Derek, 15, to a private Christian academy, where he has played on the varsity soccer and basketball teams. Mrs. Baughman hopes the state legislation requiring access will pass so that her 12-year-old son, Brandon, can join the high school lacrosse team while continuing to be educated at home.

"Some families don't want to mix in," said Mrs. Baughman, who gave up a career as a commercial photographer to teach her children. "We're not like that."

Brian Barnhart, assistant superintendent of the 3,250-student Lampeter-Strasburg School District, said the school board remained unconvinced that home-schooled children could be held to the same standards as public school students.

Mr. Barnhart said many parents also worried that home-schooled students would take coveted positions from public school students. "We see extracurricular activities as a reward for students who are complying and who are working through school," he said.

Tim Allwein, assistant executive director of the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, said many boards believed that allowing home-schooled students into sports and clubs would be an administrative nightmare that raised questions about costs, transportation and liability. For that reason, the association opposes the state bill, saying the decision should be left to the individual districts.

"The single main ingredient to making this work is to have a school board that is open to the idea," Mr. Allwein said. "Not all of them have been."

Such arguments infuriate home-schooling advocates, who say hundreds of districts in many states have resolved those issues.

"It's institutional prejudice," said Senator Rick Santorum, a Pennsylvania Republican whose wife is home-schooling the couple's four school-age children. "It's offensive."

The Pennsylvania State Education Association, the state teachers' union, has joined the school board association in opposing the legislation, which was sponsored by State Senator Bob Regola, a Republican from near Pittsburgh, and would require districts to allow home-schooled students to participate in extracurricular activities.

Nevertheless, the bill was approved by the Senate Education Committee, and opponents and supporters give it a strong chance of clearing both houses of the Republican-controlled legislature this fall. It is not clear, however, whether Gov. Edward G. Rendell, a Democrat, would sign it.

"He will review the bill when it reaches his desk, but he believes that this is a local decision," said Kate Philips, the governor's spokeswoman.

Both Abram and Andrew Mellinger said that if the bill became law, they would probably return home for their education but continue playing sports and music at the high school.

"I'd love to have them back," said Mrs. Mellinger, who is also home-schooling three of her four other children. "But I can't provide all the opportunities they need. We can practice music. But we can't put together an orchestra."

By James Dao
June 22, 2005
The New York Times
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/22/education/22home.html


LEARNING BY ACTING
Camp helps kids with disorders add to skills

Eight-year-old Christopher Cobb rolled on the floor in an office of the Learning Disabilities Association of Kentucky a few weeks ago and meowed like a kitten.

Although some people might have thought Christopher, who will be a third-grader at Jeffersontown Elementary School, was just acting like an imaginative child, he was actually learning to get along with children his age by acting out a scene from a book.

Christopher is one of about 20 children involved in the association's summer drama camp. The camp, led by Shannon Woolley, is designed to help children with learning differences, such as attention deficit disorder, acquire social skills through drama and role-playing.

But to Christopher, the camp doesn't feel like work. It feels like fun.

"This is so exciting," he said, clasping his hands.

The Learning Disabilities Association of Kentucky is a nonprofit statewide group that helps people with learning differences ranging from dyslexia to dysgraphia. The latter is a condition that makes it difficult to express oneself through writing.

The association also offers support to parents, educators and other service providers. Its offices are on Goldsmith Lane.

Campers have been meeting every Thursday and Friday since the beginning of the month. Younger children, ages 6 to 10, meet in the morning; those 11 to 17 years old gather in the afternoon.

The cost of the monthlong program is $50 per child. The association also received $1,500 from Alternative ROOTS, the Nathan Cummings Foundation and the Ford Foundation to help pay for the program.

Tim Woods, executive director of the association, said drama can be used to reach children who have learning differences. Woods said there are few camps suited to their needs.

"Usually kids with learning differences excel in something," he said. "It may not be a particular academic process, but they excel in something. Many times it's the arts."

This is the first year for the drama camp. Woolley, who has a master's degree in educational theater from New York University, said the sessions with the younger children are designed to help them learn to focus and to cooperate with others.

The children read stories and are asked to act out scenes from them. But the acting isn't meant to be rigid or "by the book," Woolley said.

"It's not a traditional drama class," she said.

The point is to encourage children to recognize the sequence of events, "which can be difficult for dyslexic kids to do," Woolley said.

"With the young ones, I just see them gaining so much self-esteem and learning to support one another's work," she said.

The classes for the older children focus on skills necessary to work in an ensemble. The students learn how to use their voices and bodies to create characters, and they also study characters from literature.

Also, they create and script scenes based on their own lives.

"I think the experience of being able to work in an ensemble gives you skills and tools that you'll be able to use throughout your life, really," Woolley said. "I would really like to see them feel like they have a community at the end of the summer that they want to continue with."

Sarah Kinney, Christopher's 11-year-old sister, is also a camper. Sarah is a sixth-grader at Carrithers Middle School and has attention deficit disorder, dyslexia and Asperger's syndrome, a mild form of autism. She said she loves drama camp.

"I really like it because I get to do a lot of fun stuff," Sarah said. "It's really fun and I like the teacher and I like the other people there."

Campers will share what they've learned at 11 a.m. Friday at Northeast Christian Church, 9900 Brownsboro Road. From 11 to noon the younger children will engage their parents in activities they've learned, and from noon to 1 p.m. it will be the older children's turn.

Leigh Helmick of Prospect said the camp has been a good experience for her 17-year-old daughter, Lauren.

Lauren, who will be a junior at the Academy for Individual Excellence, has trouble processing language.

Helmick said it's good for her daughter to be in an environment where she's not the only one who is different.

"When you're in a group like a school setting or something like that, you may be the only one with a learning disability," she said. "It's hard to grow up. It's good to be around other people who are experiencing the same thing."

In addition to helping the children, the camp also helps parents, said Lynne Cobb, Christopher and Sarah's mother. Cobb said she's been able to use acting as a way to get through to them.

"I've been able to use things like if she's refusing to eat something I say, 'Well, why don't you use your great acting skills and pretend that you like it,' and it works," Cobb said.

But the real payoff is for the children, said Charles Schoene, whose son William is a camper. William, a 9-year-old who will be in the fourth grade at Cochrane Elementary School in Jeffersontown, has attention deficit disorder and is suspected to have Asperger's syndrome.

"Our goal was to increase his socialization skills so he would get along better with his peers and relate better and communicate better," Schoene said. "I just want him to know that he's not alone and that there are other people with similar problems."

By Scheri Smith
Wednesday, June 22, 2005
The Courier-Journal
http://www.courier-journal.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050622/NEWS0102/506220303



Video game helps combat ADHD
Interactive program boosts reading: Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder's worst enemy: Dance Dance Revolution

Struggling young readers with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder can improve their reading skills by playing a popular video game that involves dancing, a new study suggests.

The study probed whether the interactive game Dance Dance Revolution could improve reading by matching movements to visual and rhythmic auditory cues and strengthening the neural networks involved in reading and attention.

The game had a positive effect on a key skill used in reading known as receptive coding, the study found. This skill involves the ability of a child to code whole written words into short-term memory.

"You're not talking about medication. You're not taking about individual tutors. That's the promise," said lead researcher Tammy McGraw.

"We are encouraged, and more research needs to be done. Here is a situation where we know that if children do not learn to read, they're going to be struggling throughout their lives. Here's something that children are just naturally inclined to want to do, and with the prevalence of PlayStation, it's something that we can use in the home."

The findings of the study, funded by the U.S. Department of Education and conducted by a team of educational researchers headed by McGraw in West Virginia, were released in Vancouver yesterday at the Digital Games Research Association conference, hosted by Simon Fraser University.

The study is just the latest one to urge educators to include commercial computer games as legitimate tools for academic and social learning at school.

The 62 participants, all Grade 6 students with ADHD who struggled with reading, were split into two groups - those receiving treatment and those in the control group, who did not participate in the intervention activity.

Treatment involved playing Dance Dance Revolution.

The game includes a platform with four arrows, on which the player steps in accordance with matching patterns on the screen in front of them.

The dancing game, which allows players to pick the music to which they'd like to move, was first introduced at arcades in 1998, but the series has since expanded to a home-based PlayStation version.

Participants in the treatment group attended two 25-minute sessions each week for either four, eight or 12 weeks.

All students completed a reading test before and after treatment.

The study found that the intervention helped with receptive coding, one of the subtests of the reading test; participants in the treatment group gained two points from the pretest and post-test, compared with a gain of less than one point in the control group.

For a Grade 6 student, the receptive coding subtest requires looking at a target word for only one second before viewing a page with letters to determine whether they were in the previous word in the correct order. The subtest also asks the student to look at a target word for only one second before viewing a page with a letter to determine if it was in the previous word.

In addition to testing the ability to code written words into short-term memory, attention is also vital because the target word is presented only briefly.

The study also found that the number of treatment sessions had a positive effect on the gains made by treatment group participants in the receptive coding subtest.

"(The apparent correlation) makes me really curious about what's going on with this game in terms of helping the kids become better with their receptive coding skills," said study co-author Kristine Chadwick.

McGraw said the next step is more research with larger sample sizes, other video games, struggling young readers without ADHD, or kids with ADHD but without reading impairment.

By Sarah Schmidt CanWest News Service
June 28, 2005
Canada.com © The Gazette (Montreal) 2005 http://www.canada.com/technology/story.html?id=303b86e1-4eb2-42d7-892c-fe33d061b7e9